A Norfolk tip will shut by December, after county councillors decided to axe it, saying it was no longer "fit for purpose".
But the decision sparked anger, with accusations Norfolk County Council ignored hundreds of people who wanted Mayton Wood Recycling Centre, near Coltishall, to stay open.
The Conservative-controlled cabinet voted unanimously to shut the tip when it met on Monday (October 2).
The council will save £70,000 by closing the tip, with council leaders saying the site was now "out-of-date".
They said people could instead use the recently built Norwich North recycling centre, with better access and fewer queues.
Officers at County Hall had recommended Mayton Wood for closure, saying usage has dropped since Norwich North, off the Northern Distributor Road, opened.
And Andrew Jamieson, the council's cabinet member for finance, said: "It's not that we are simply closing a recycling centre. We have spent £2.8m on a new recycling centre."
Mr Jamieson said Mayton Wood was "old and out-of-date" and that investment in new recycling centres would mean people would get better services at others - even though that would mean they had to travel further.
He said he did not accept the argument that could lead to more fly-tipping. He said travelling further to get rid of rubbish would not make people "heave it into the nearest ditch".
Fellow Conservative county councillor Greg Peck said the tip was "not fit for purpose".
But Dan Roper, Liberal Democrat councillor for Hevingham and Spixworth, said: "This was a done deal, the consultation was a sham as the cabinet completely ignored the 92pc of responses who opposed closure.
"By some warped logic, the Tories present closure as an 'improved service' and it was particularly sad to hear cabinet members denigrating this well-used recycling centre that is much valued by residents."
READ MORE: Norfolk recycling centres could introduce time slots
Steve Morphew, leader of the opposition Labour group, said: "It's staggering that the discussion about the closure of Mayton Wood made no reference to the consultation that showed such overwhelming opposition to closure.
"Now let's see this Conservative administration tell Norfolk how they listen to and take account of our views. Pull the other one."
The county council has said it could have to consider introducing time slots for people wanting to head to tips - with the government set to allow people to get rid of more DIY waste for free.
Comments: Our rules
We want our comments to be a lively and valuable part of our community - a place where readers can debate and engage with the most important local issues. The ability to comment on our stories is a privilege, not a right, however, and that privilege may be withdrawn if it is abused or misused.
Please report any comments that break our rules.
Read the rules here